When Old Favorites Let Us Down: Revisiting Beloved Games
On a recent episode of Good Playing With You, we tackled a bittersweet topic that many gamers can relate to: replaying a favorite game and finding out it’s not as good as we remembered. It’s a tricky feeling—equal parts nostalgia and disappointment—and during the discussion, each of us shared our experiences.
The Thing Remastered: Nostalgia Hits a Wall
Matt Lord kicked things off with his experience revisiting The Thing Remastered. As a huge fan of the original PS2 game, he was excited to dive back into the paranoia and survival mechanics that defined his younger gaming years. However, the remaster didn’t hold up as well as he’d hoped. He explained, "The controls are just not intuitive, the puzzles are frustrating because they’re essentially just running back and forth, and the shooting mechanics feel really static." Despite his deep love for the original, Matt concluded that The Thing was better left as a fond memory.
Not every revisit ends in disappointment, though. Lord highlighted Red Dead Redemption Remastered as an example of a game that still holds up beautifully. Playing it on his Steam Deck, he praised its timeless storytelling and gameplay, describing it as "a joy to rediscover."
Hitman: Blood Money—A Tough Look Back
I brought up Hitman: Blood Money, a game I adored back in the Xbox 360 days. Going backwards in time after playing Hitman: World of Assassination is tough. Hoping to recapture the thrill of elaborate assassinations, I found myself struggling with the dated graphics and slower mechanics. While the game still has its charm, the improvements made in newer installments make the classic feel clunky by comparison.
On the other hand, Far Cry 3 Remastered, held up exceptionally well during my recent playthrough. The graphics are nothing to sneeze at, even if they are dated, and the gameplay feels as smooth as I remember. The story—a doofus frat boy transforming into the savior of his friends—is still the best in the series. It’s way more engaging than the newer Far Cry games, and it’s a great reminder of how good the franchise was at its peak.
Silent Hill 2 Remake: The Drag of Added Fluff
Dan shared his experience revisiting Silent Hill 2 Remake and Far Cry Blood Dragon. Despite being one of his all-time favorite games, the Silent Hill 2 Remake left him cold. "I’m halfway through the apartment complex, and it feels like they’ve added more to pad it out, and what they’ve added is just too much fluff for me," he said. While the story remains compelling, the additional content and slower pacing detracted from the magic he remembered. As for Far Cry Blood Dragon, Dan said, "The voice acting is still fantastic, but the gameplay and graphics didn’t age as gracefully as I’d hoped. It’s just a bit too small and dated for today’s standards."
Why Old Favorites Sometimes Fall Short
So why do beloved games sometimes fail to live up to our memories? Nostalgia often amplifies the best parts of a game, while time exposes its flaws. As gaming technology and design evolve, older mechanics can feel clunky or outdated. These experiences don’t erase the joy we felt playing these games the first time around, but sometimes it’s better to preserve the memory than to revisit the reality.
Share Your Thoughts
Have you replayed a favorite game and had a similar experience? Or are there classics that still hold up as well as you remember? Let us know your stories in the comments or email us at goodplayingwithyou@gmail.com.
Thanks for reading, and remember: sometimes the past is best left in the past. Good playing with you!
Sound off below and let me know what you think!